Discovering The Rarest Squishmallows List: Your Ultimate Collector's Guide

Genevieve Schmeler 16 Aug 2025

Are you someone who loves those wonderfully soft, cuddly Squishmallows? Perhaps you've heard whispers about certain characters being super hard to find, or maybe you're just starting your collection and want to know which ones are the true gems. Well, you're certainly not alone! It's almost like a treasure hunt for many fans, and the excitement of finding a truly special Squishmallow is, you know, pretty big. People everywhere are always looking for the next big find, and some of these plush pals have become quite sought after.

There's a whole world of Squishmallows out there, with new friends appearing all the time and some older ones becoming legendary. What makes a Squishmallow rare can be a few things: maybe it was a limited production, or it was only sold at a specific store for a short time, or perhaps it was an exclusive event item. Understanding these factors can really help you when you're out looking for your next addition, or even just curious about the value of your own collection.

This guide is here to help you get a better feel for what makes a Squishmallow truly special and to show you some of the most elusive characters that collectors dream about. We'll go over some specific examples, talk about what gives them their rarity, and even share some tips for your own collecting adventures. So, if you're ready to learn about the most coveted Squishmallows, just keep reading, you know.

What Makes a Squishmallow Rare?
The Rarest Squishmallows You Might Find
Tips for Your Rare Squishmallow Hunt
Spotting Authentic Squishmallows
Frequently Asked Questions About Rare Squishmallows
Your Squishmallow Collecting Adventure

What Makes a Squishmallow Rare?

So, what exactly makes one of these soft toys harder to find than others? It's not just about how cute they are, though that certainly helps! There are several reasons why a Squishmallow might become a rare item, and understanding these can really help you figure out what to look for. It's almost like knowing the secret recipe, you know.

Limited Production Runs

Some Squishmallows are simply made in very small quantities. These are often special editions or ones that were released for a very short time. When only a few thousand, or even just a few hundred, are made, they naturally become much more difficult to get your hands on. This is a big reason why certain ones are so highly valued, honestly.

Retailer Exclusives

Many Squishmallows are made exclusively for a particular store, like a specific grocery chain or a big box retailer. If you don't live near that store, or if they only carried it for a little while, finding it can be quite a challenge. This means that a Squishmallow might be common in one area but practically impossible to find somewhere else, which is a bit interesting.

Event and Convention Exclusives

Every now and then, a Squishmallow is released only at a special event, like a toy fair or a comic convention. These are usually very limited and only available to people who attend the event. Once the event is over, that's usually it for that particular Squishmallow, making them incredibly rare. It's almost like a special prize for those who were there.

Older and Discontinued Squishmallows

Just like anything else, Squishmallows get retired. When a certain design or character is no longer produced, the existing ones become more valuable over time, especially if they were popular to begin with. The older the Squishmallow, and the fewer that were made, the rarer it tends to be. This is a pretty common pattern for collectibles, you know.

Tag Variations and Errors

Sometimes, a Squishmallow might have a unique tag or a slight variation that was corrected later. These "error" tags or early versions can be quite rare because they were only produced for a very short period before the change was made. Collectors often seek these out because of their uniqueness. It's kind of like finding a rare coin, in a way.

The Rarest Squishmallows You Might Find

Now, let's talk about some of the most sought-after Squishmallows that have collectors really excited. Keep in mind that rarity can shift a little, as new ones are released and older ones become harder to find. But these are some of the true legends in the Squishmallow world, really.

Jack the Black Cat

Jack is, without a doubt, one of the most famous rare Squishmallows out there. He was released in 2020 as a special limited edition, with only 500 pieces ever made. Each one even came with a special tag indicating its number in the series. Because of his extremely low production number, finding an authentic Jack is incredibly difficult and, as a matter of fact, quite expensive. He's a true holy grail for many collectors.

Fletcher the Teal Owl

Fletcher is another early and very rare Squishmallow. He was part of the original "Squad" and was released quite some time ago. What makes him special is his unique teal color, which isn't common for the owl characters. Over the years, he's become increasingly hard to find, especially in good condition with his original tags. He's a bit of a vintage find, you know.

Original Avery the Mallard

While Avery the Mallard has seen many re-releases and variations, the original 2018 version is particularly rare. This early Avery had a specific fabric texture and a slightly different tag design. Collectors who appreciate the history of Squishmallows often look for this specific version, which makes him quite a special piece. It's about that first edition feel, basically.

Stacy the Squid

Stacy the Squid, especially the older versions, has become quite a desirable Squishmallow. She was released a while back and has a really charming, unique look with her many tentacles. Like many older designs, as time goes on and production stops, the existing Stacys become more and more difficult to acquire. She's a popular one, for sure.

Philippe the Frog

Philippe the Frog is another early Squishmallow that has gained significant rarity. He's a small, vibrant green frog with adorable pink cheeks. What makes him rare is his age and the fact that he was part of some of the earlier Squishmallow releases. Finding a Philippe in excellent shape is a real win for any collector. He's just a little sweetheart, really.

Reshma the Cow

Reshma the Cow is a more recent example of a highly sought-after Squishmallow. She was released as a Barnes & Noble exclusive, which immediately limited her availability. Her cute, unique design and limited distribution made her an instant hit and very hard to find in stores. People were really looking for her, you know.

Bubba the Cow

Bubba the Cow, particularly the earlier versions, is another cow-themed Squishmallow that has become very rare. The cow Squishmallows, in general, are incredibly popular, and Bubba's specific color and design made him a favorite. When older versions of popular characters are no longer made, their value naturally goes up. He's quite the prize for cow collectors, it's almost.

OG Brina the Bigfoot

The Bigfoot Squishmallows are generally popular, but the original Brina, especially in certain sizes, has become exceptionally rare. She was one of the first Bigfoot designs, and her shaggy fur and sweet expression made her a hit. As newer versions of Bigfoot have come out, the original Brina has become a true collector's item. She's a bit of a legend, actually.

Patty the Cow (Pink Version)

Patty the Cow is another highly beloved Squishmallow, and the pink version, in particular, is very rare. She was often a limited release or an exclusive to certain retailers, making her incredibly hard to track down. Her bright pink color and friendly face make her a standout, and collectors really go out of their way to find her. She's quite special, you know.

Blake the Bunny

Blake the Bunny is an older Squishmallow that has become quite rare over time. He has a unique, somewhat sleepy expression and a soft, pastel color. Like many of the earlier characters that are no longer in production, finding a Blake in good condition with his original tags is a true find for anyone looking to complete a vintage collection. He's a classic, in a way.

Tips for Your Rare Squishmallow Hunt

Hunting for rare Squishmallows can be a really fun hobby, but it does take a bit of patience and knowing where to look. Here are some pointers to help you on your quest, really.

Check Online Marketplaces: Websites like eBay, Mercari, and Depop are common places where rare Squishmallows are sold. Be prepared for higher prices, and always check seller reviews. You can often find some pretty good deals if you're patient, you know.
Join Online Communities: There are many Facebook groups and Reddit forums dedicated to Squishmallow collecting. These communities are great for learning about new releases, finding trading partners, and getting tips on where to find specific characters. People are often very helpful there, honestly.
Visit Local Stores Regularly: Sometimes, rare Squishmallows pop up in unexpected places, like smaller toy shops or even pharmacies. Visiting these stores often, especially after new stock arrives, can sometimes lead to a lucky find. It's a bit of a commitment, but it can pay off.
Attend Local Conventions or Fairs: If there are toy or collectible conventions in your area, it's worth checking them out. Sometimes, vendors will have rare Squishmallows that are hard to find elsewhere. You might just stumble upon something amazing, you know.
Understand Rarity Factors: Knowing why a Squishmallow is rare (limited edition, exclusive, discontinued) helps you prioritize your search. This way, you're not just looking for "any" rare one, but a specific type. It's about being smart with your search, basically.

You can learn more about supporting children’s educational success on our site, which is something we care a lot about. It's a good thing to think about, really.

Spotting Authentic Squishmallows

With the popularity of rare Squishmallows, unfortunately, fake ones do appear on the market. It's really important to know how to tell if a Squishmallow is real, especially when you're paying a lot for a rare one. Here are some things to look for, you know.

Check the Tags: Authentic Squishmallows always come with two tags: a hang tag (the paper one) and a tush tag (the fabric one sewn into the plush). Both should have the official Squishmallows logo. The hang tag often has a unique character bio, and the tush tag will list the materials and care instructions. It's a pretty clear indicator, honestly.
Feel the Fabric: Real Squishmallows are known for their incredibly soft, marshmallow-like texture. If the fabric feels rough, stiff, or just "off," it might be a fake. The stuffing should also be very squishy and not too firm. It's a very distinct feel, you know.
Examine the Stitching: Authentic Squishmallows have neat, even stitching. If you see loose threads, uneven seams, or poor construction, that's a red flag. The quality control is usually quite good on real ones. They tend to be well put together, really.
Look at the Proportions: While there can be slight variations, real Squishmallows generally have consistent proportions for their size and character. If something looks disproportionate or oddly shaped, it could be a counterfeit. It's almost like they have a certain look, you know.
Purchase from Reputable Sellers: Whenever possible, buy from official retailers or well-known, trusted sellers on secondary markets. Be wary of deals that seem too good to be true, as they often are. It's always better to be safe than sorry, you know.

Our dedicated family service specialists will work personally to understand your family’s needs and identify the best enrollment options, and you can find out more about Centro de la Familia de Utah's programs by visiting our site. We're here to help, really.

Frequently Asked Questions About Rare Squishmallows

People often have a lot of questions about rare Squishmallows, and that's totally understandable! Here are some common ones that come up, you know.

What is the rarest Squishmallow ever made?

While opinions can vary slightly, many collectors agree that Jack the Black Cat, especially the 500-piece limited edition, is considered the rarest Squishmallow ever made due to his extremely low production number and specific serialization. He's very, very hard to find, honestly.

How can I tell if my Squishmallow is rare?

You can often tell if your Squishmallow is rare by checking its release date, where it was originally sold (if it was an exclusive), and if it has any unique features like special tags or limited edition numbers. Researching online collector communities and rarity guides can also help. It's a bit like detective work, you know.

Do rare Squishmallows increase in value?

Yes, rare Squishmallows can definitely increase in value, especially if they are highly sought after by collectors and are no longer produced. Their value often depends on their condition, whether they have their original tags, and how many were originally made. It's a bit of a market, really.

Your Squishmallow Collecting Adventure

Collecting Squishmallows, especially the rare ones, is a truly rewarding hobby for many people. It's a way to connect with a fun community, enjoy the thrill of the hunt, and build a collection of incredibly soft and charming plush friends. Whether you're just starting out or you're a seasoned collector, the world of Squishmallows always has something new and exciting to offer. It's a really good feeling to find that special one, you know.

Remember, the most important thing is to enjoy the process and collect what makes you happy. While rarity is certainly exciting, every Squishmallow, rare or not, brings a little bit of joy. Happy hunting, and may your collection be filled with many wonderful and perhaps even some very rare finds! It's a lot of fun, honestly.

8 of the Rarest and Most Expensive Squishmallows Ever Sold - Rarest.org

VeriScope News

Discovering The Rarest Squishmallows List: Your Ultimate Collector's Guide

Table of Contents