What Is The Rarest Squishmallow? Uncovering Those Hard-to-Find Plush Friends

Shanna Erdman 16 Aug 2025

Completing your Squishmallow collection can, in a way, feel like a treasure hunt, and it will often cost you a pretty penny. These soft, plush animal toys, brought to life by Kelly Toys, a Jazwares company, have quite simply captured hearts everywhere since the brand began in 2017. Many folks, you know, really enjoy finding these cuddly companions, but some are much, much harder to come across than others.

There's a real thrill, it seems, in tracking down those exclusive and coveted plush toys that not everyone has. It’s a bit like finding a hidden gem, and that feeling of discovery is, for many, a big part of the fun. So, if you're wondering just what makes some of these squishy friends so elusive, you're certainly not alone.

We’re going to take a look at what truly makes a Squishmallow rare, exploring some of the most sought-after characters out there. You’ll get to learn about identifying these special editions and, well, get a sense of why some are just so unexpectedly hard to find these days. It’s quite a fascinating world, really, when you start looking at the rarest of the rare.

Understanding Squishmallow Rarity: What Makes Them Special?
- Factors Influencing Rarity
- The Value of Rarity
The Top Rarest Squishmallows to Know
How to Spot a Rare Squishmallow
- Looking for Limited Editions and Exclusivity
- Design, Features, and Demand
Frequently Asked Questions About Rare Squishmallows
Starting Your Own Rare Squishmallow Hunt

Understanding Squishmallow Rarity: What Makes Them Special?

When you think about collecting anything, whether it's stamps or, well, these cuddly plush toys, some items just naturally stand out as being harder to get. For Squishmallows, this idea of rarity isn't just about how old a toy is, though that can play a part. It's more about a combination of things that make certain ones really special and, you know, very sought after.

Factors Influencing Rarity

Identifying rare Squishmallows, it turns out, requires a bit of knowledge and, well, some research too. There are several key things that can make a Squishmallow quite hard to find. Limited editions are, for example, a big one. When Kelly Toy Holdings LLC launches a Squishmallow brand, some are only made for a short time or in very small numbers. This immediately makes them, you know, more exclusive.

Exclusivity also plays a huge role. Some Squishmallows are only available at certain stores, or perhaps just for a special event. This means you can't just find them anywhere, which, in a way, drives up their desirability. The design and unique features of a Squishmallow can also make it rare. If a particular color combination or a special little detail is only on a few, those will, quite naturally, become more valuable.

And then there's demand, which is, you know, pretty important. If a Squishmallow becomes incredibly popular, and lots of people want it but there aren't many available, its value and rarity will, of course, shoot up. So, it's a mix of how they're made, where they're sold, what they look like, and how many people really, really want them.

The Value of Rarity

The phrase "completing your Squishmallow collection will cost you a pretty penny" really rings true when you start looking at the rare ones. These exclusive and coveted plush toys, as a matter of fact, often fetch high prices on auction sites or from private sellers. It’s not just about the soft, plush feel anymore; it’s about the hunt and the bragging rights, you know?

For collectors, the value isn't just monetary, either. It's also about the satisfaction of owning something truly special that few others possess. The thrill of finding one of these unexpectedly hard-to-find items is, well, a reward in itself. This focus on unique items is, quite honestly, what keeps the collecting community vibrant and always looking for the next big find.

The Top Rarest Squishmallows to Know

So, you're probably wondering, what is the rarest Squishmallow out there? While it's tough to pick just one definitive "rarest in the world" because, you know, new ones come out and demand shifts, we can certainly uncover some of the most sought-after and valuable ones. These are the Squishmallows that, as a matter of fact, often appear on lists of the top 10 or 15 rarest.

Jack the Black Cat

Jack the Black Cat is, without a doubt, one of the names that pops up very often when people talk about rare Squishmallows. He's a sleek, dark feline, and his limited availability has made him a true collector's item. For many, finding Jack is like, well, hitting the jackpot. His simple yet striking design, you know, just appeals to so many people, making him incredibly hard to get your hands on these days.

Stacy the Squid

Stacy the Squid is another one that collectors are always talking about. This particular Squishmallow, with her unique look, has been among the 10 rarest and most expensive Squishmallows ever sold on auction sites. Her distinct shape and colors, you know, really make her stand out from the crowd, making her a prized possession for anyone lucky enough to find her. She's, quite simply, a fan favorite that's become super hard to acquire.

Blossom the Lamb

Blossom the Lamb is, in some respects, a truly special one. Aside from being one of the rarest, Blossom the sheep, as she's sometimes called, looks like she’s also one of the sleepiest of the Squishmallow gang. When he tries to fall, well, he's just so soft and cuddly. This sleepy, gentle appearance, you know, really adds to her charm and makes her incredibly popular, which, of course, contributes to her rarity.

Emily the Bat in Pumpkin

Emily the Bat in Pumpkin, too, holds a special place on many rare lists. This particular Squishmallow, often seen around Halloween, is quite unique because of her seasonal theme and the fact that she's, well, inside a pumpkin. This specific design and the limited time she was available mean she's very, very hard to find now. She's definitely one that collectors often talk about when discussing those truly special, hard-to-get pieces.

Santino the Platypus

Santino the Platypus is another character that often appears on lists of the 15 rarest Squishmallows. Platypuses aren't as common in the Squishmallow lineup as, say, cats or dogs, and Santino's particular design and availability have made him quite sought after. His unique animal type, you know, just adds to his appeal for collectors looking for something a bit different.

Avery the Mallard

Avery the Mallard is, quite simply, another Squishmallow that has reached legendary status among collectors. This charming duck has been among the 10 rarest and most expensive Squishmallows ever sold on auction sites. His classic, friendly look, you know, makes him a favorite, and his scarcity just pushes his value way up. Finding Avery is, for many, a true triumph in the collecting world.

Brina the Bigfoot

Brina the Bigfoot is, well, a fuzzy friend who has also made a name for herself as one of the rarest. Like Avery and Stacy, Brina has been noted among the most expensive Squishmallows ever sold at auction. Her unique, somewhat mythical creature design, combined with limited releases, makes her incredibly desirable. She's, quite frankly, one of those Squishmallows that everyone wants but few can actually find.

Archie the Axolotl

Archie the Axolotl is, in a way, a standout. With its unique color and, you know, really cute expression, Archie has become a favorite among collectors. While not always listed as the absolute rarest, his popularity and the specific versions of Archie that are harder to find mean he's often included in discussions about valuable and sought-after Squishmallows. He's a very beloved character, which, of course, can make certain editions of him quite elusive.

How to Spot a Rare Squishmallow

So, how do you go about identifying the rarest and most valuable Squishmallows? It’s not just about luck, you know; there’s a bit of strategy involved. Learning how to identify these special ones can, quite frankly, save you a lot of time and, well, money too. Here are some tips to help you spot a rare Squishmallow when you're out hunting for them.

Looking for Limited Editions and Exclusivity

One of the first things to look for is whether a Squishmallow is part of a limited edition or an exclusive release. These are, by their very nature, going to be harder to find. Sometimes, you know, a Squishmallow is made just for a specific holiday, or maybe for a particular store chain. These kinds of details are often found on their tags or, well, in official announcements. Keeping up with Squishmallow news and fan communities can really help you stay informed about these special drops. Learn more about Squishmallows on our site, for instance, to keep up with the latest information.

Checking the release date and the production run can also give you clues. Older Squishmallows, especially those from the earlier years like 2017, tend to be rarer simply because fewer were made and, well, they've been around longer. Similarly, if a Squishmallow was only available for a very short period, it’s highly likely to be quite rare now. So, a little research into its history can, you know, really tell you a lot.

Design, Features, and Demand

The actual design and unique features of a Squishmallow are, of course, also important indicators of rarity. Look for unique colors, special textures, or even particular accessories that aren't common on other Squishmallows. For example, if a Squishmallow has an unusual pattern or a very specific facial expression that's different from the usual ones, that might be a sign. These small details can, you know, make a big difference in its collectibility.

Finally, demand is a huge factor. While you can't always predict it, keeping an eye on what Squishmallows are trending or being talked about a lot in collector groups can give you a clue. If everyone is suddenly looking for a particular character, its value and rarity will, quite naturally, increase. Checking auction sites to see which Squishmallows are selling for high prices can also give you a good idea of current demand. You might also want to explore our list of these exclusive and coveted plush toys to see what others are looking for.

Frequently Asked Questions About Rare Squishmallows

People often have questions about these special plush friends, especially when they're thinking about starting or adding to their collection. Here are a few common ones that collectors, you know, often ask.

What makes a Squishmallow valuable?

A Squishmallow becomes valuable based on several things, really. Limited editions, how exclusive it is (meaning where it was sold and for how long), its unique design and features, and, very importantly, the demand for it among collectors. If lots of people want it and there aren't many around, it's going to be, well, quite valuable.

Are older Squishmallows always rarer?

Not always, but often. Older Squishmallows, especially those from the very early days, tend to be rarer simply because fewer were produced back then, and, you know, they've been out of production for a longer time. However, a newer Squishmallow can also be incredibly rare if it was a very limited release or a highly sought-after exclusive.

How can I avoid buying fake rare Squishmallows?

To avoid fakes, it's a good idea to, well, really pay attention to the details. Always check the tags; authentic Squishmallows have specific tags with their name, bio, and production information. Look at the stitching and the overall quality of the plush; genuine ones are very well made. Buying from reputable sellers or official retailers is, quite frankly, your best bet, too. If a deal seems too good to be true, it, you know, probably is.

Starting Your Own Rare Squishmallow Hunt

So, whether you're just starting your collection or looking to add some truly special pieces, the world of rare Squishmallows is, you know, pretty exciting. From Jack the Black Cat to Stacy the Squid, these plush friends hold a unique charm and, well, significant value for collectors. It’s a hobby that combines the joy of collecting with the thrill of the chase.

Remember, identifying rare Squishmallows requires a bit of knowledge and, well, research. By paying attention to factors like limited editions, exclusivity, design, features, and demand, you can increase your chances of finding those coveted plush toys. Keep an eye out for those unexpectedly hard-to-find gems, and, you know, happy hunting! The journey to complete your collection, or just find that one special Squishmallow, is, quite simply, part of the fun. For more details on collecting, you might want to visit the official Squishmallows website.

The 10 Rarest And Most Expensive Squishmallows Ever Sold, 60% OFF

What Is The Rarest Squishmallow? (2023 Updated), 42% OFF

Squishmallow Rarity: The Most Rarest-to-Find Plushies on the Market.

VeriScope News